When We Strongly Disagree

Rev. Richard Smith

January 22, 2024

Ephesians 4:5-6 (Words of The Apostle Paul)

Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in love. Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace. 

Disagreeing with one another on key religious, social, ethical issues is not in and of itself an issue.  Even passionately disagreeing can be okay.  The problem comes when any of us refuse to listen to others, castigate those who disagree, or infer that one’s own perception of truth is categorically right.  ow do we find constructive ways to interact with one another when the tensions are high?

ACCEPT THAT NONE OF US HAVE ALL THE ANSWERS

  Accepting that one cannot claim absolute truth or knowledge is always the starting point to a healthy way of interacting with others.  It leads to dialogue, to sincere listening, and to prospective relationship even in strong disagreement.  Whoever you are, however deep your spiritual commitment, however Biblically studied you are, none of us can wear the badge of absolute wisdom; of absolutely knowing God’s will and intent.

The essential virtue we each need here is humility!  Sincere humility can build bridges.

PRACTICE CIVILITY AND SENSITIVITY

Praying for and seeking to live with civility, humility, and sensitivity is foundational if we are going to have constructive conversations on critical matters.

You and I cannot control how others respond or react, but we can be sure that our own tone and tenor are healthy; and are reflective of a Jesus-grounded life.

One can be right on an issue, but also be wrong in the spirit of Jesus if we are insensitive, belligerent, and judgmental toward the ones with whom we disagree

CONSTRUCTIVELY DISCERN YOUR LINE IN THE SAND

There are matters of justice and goodness which simply cannot be tolerated.  We should not tolerate any position of unacceptable mistreatment of others.  We should not allow others to disdain those of different ethnic status or sexual orientation or religious conviction or gender status.  We should not allow hateful and harmful words and actions to go unaddressed. 

When there is injustice, when persons perpetuate inhumane actions, when there is clear mistreatment of other human beings, God expects us to step up and stand up!

Again, however, with God’s help, we must do our best, even as we draw the line, not to fall prey to unhealthy personal attacks and to denigration of those with whom we strongly disagree.  We can strongly challenge their views and their actions without becoming the shallow persons they seem to be. 

INDEED, PRAY

Pray for humility and honest awareness of your own selfhood.

Pray for insight into the Biblical references speaking to the issues.

Pray for strength to be as kind as possible.

Pray for discernment about the other person’s situation and background.

Pray to be able to live Romans 12:18:  If it is possible, as far as it depends on you, live at peace with everyone.